Friday, May 25, 2018

Atlas Shrugged Outline

The U.S. Library of Congress has called "Atlas Shrugged" the second most influential book ever written (with the first being the Bible).

Ayn HERSELF wrote the following in "The Romantic Manifesto":
"The motive and purpose of my writing can best be summed up by saying that if a dedication page were to precede the total of my work, it would read: To the glory of Man."

"And if anyone should ask me what it is that I have said to the glory of Man, I will answer only by paraphrasing Howard Roark. I will hold up a copy of Atlas Shrugged and say: 'The explanation rests.'"

This means "Atlas Shrugged" is Ayn's best explanation for her beliefs...

The purpose of these notes is to help people understand this epic novel. Many people have told me I they would never had made it past Chapter 5 without these notes.

The notes are set up with the following sections:

PLOT:
The events that occur in the chapter that come to conclusion.

SUBPLOT:
The events that occur during the chapter that are important to remember during future chapters.

COMMENTS:
Insight into the events that occurred during the chapter from a principle perspective.

PRACTICAL APPLICATION:
A review of a section of the chapter that is worth re-reading because it can be practically applied to your life.

SUPPLEMENT:
Quotes and examples from other works that add further insight to the principles in the chapter.

Those who have read "Atlas Shrugged" find the best way to re-read the book is to read the notes and then re-read the section mentioned in PRACTICAL APPLICATION.

The links to the notes can be found in the following table of contents.

Part 1: NON-CONTRADICTION
Chapter 1: The Theme
Chapter 2: The Chain
Chapter 3: The Top and the Bottom
Chapter 4: The Immovable Movers
Chapter 5: The Climax of the d'Anconias
Chapter 6: The Non-Commercial
Chapter 7: The Exploiters and the Exploited
Chapter 8: The John Galt Line
Chapter 9: The Sacred and the Profane
Chapter 10: Wyatt's Torch

Part 2: EITHER-OR
Chapter 1: The Man Who Belonged on Earth
Chapter 2: The Aristocracy of Pull
Chapter 3: White Blackmail
Chapter 4: The Sanction of the Victim
Chapter 5: Account Overdrawn
Chapter 6: Miracle Metal
Chapter 7: The Moratorium on Brains
Chapter 8: By Our Love
Chapter 9: The Face Without Pain or Fear or Guilt
Chapter 10: The Sign of the Dollar

Part 3: A IS A
Link to Outline: Part 3

Thursday, May 24, 2018

Atlas Outline with Part III

The U.S. Library of Congress has called "Atlas Shrugged" the second most influential book ever written (with the first being the Bible).

Ayn HERSELF wrote the following in "The Romantic Manifesto":
"The motive and purpose of my writing can best be summed up by saying that if a dedication page were to precede the total of my work, it would read: To the glory of Man."

"And if anyone should ask me what it is that I have said to the glory of Man, I will answer only by paraphrasing Howard Roark. I will hold up a copy of Atlas Shrugged and say: 'The explanation rests.'"

This means "Atlas Shrugged" is Ayn's best explanation for her beliefs...

The purpose of these notes is to help people understand this epic novel. Many people have told me I they would never had made it past Chapter 5 without these notes.

The notes are set up with the following sections:

PLOT:
The events that occur in the chapter that come to conclusion.

SUBPLOT:
The events that occur during the chapter that are important to remember during future chapters.

COMMENTS:
Insight into the events that occurred during the chapter from a principle perspective.

PRACTICAL APPLICATION:
A review of a section of the chapter that is worth re-reading because it can be practically applied to your life.

SUPPLEMENT:
Quotes and examples from other works that add further insight to the principles in the chapter.

Those who have read "Atlas Shrugged" find the best way to re-read the book is to read the notes and then re-read the section mentioned in PRACTICAL APPLICATION.

The links to the notes can be found in the following table of contents.

Part 1: NON-CONTRADICTION
Chapter 1: The Theme
Chapter 2: The Chain
Chapter 3: The Top and the Bottom
Chapter 4: The Immovable Movers
Chapter 5: The Climax of the d'Anconias
Chapter 6: The Non-Commercial
Chapter 7: The Exploiters and the Exploited
Chapter 8: The John Galt Line
Chapter 9: The Sacred and the Profane
Chapter 10: Wyatt's Torch

Part 2: EITHER-OR
Chapter 1: The Man Who Belonged on Earth
Chapter 2: The Aristocracy of Pull
Chapter 3: White Blackmail
Chapter 4: The Sanction of the Victim
Chapter 5: Account Overdrawn
Chapter 6: Miracle Metal
Chapter 7: The Moratorium on Brains
Chapter 8: By Our Love
Chapter 9: The Face Without Pain or Fear or Guilt
Chapter 10: The Sign of the Dollar

Part 3: A IS A
Chapter 1: Atlantis
Chapter 2: The Utopia of Greed
Chapter 3: Anti-Greed
Chapter 4: Anti-Life
Chapter 5: Their Brothers' Keepers
Chapter 6: The Concerto of Deliverance
Chapter 7: This Is John Galt Speaking
Chapter 8: The Egoist
Chapter 9: The Generator
Chapter 10: In the Name of the Best Within Us

Atlas Shrugged Conclusion Post

Monday, April 30, 2018

Atlas Shrugged Conclusion

PRACTICAL APPLICATION (worth rereading)
The entire novel is worth rereading if a person doesn't understand and take the next steps...

During a 1961 lecture tour, Ayn was asked a question after her presentation at Purdue University: "Should all of us go on strike? If not, what should we be doing?"

Ayn stated the events of Atlas Shrugged are meant to take place ten years in the future from the reader's time. She then said once a culture goes through the things in the novel, it would be moral to go on strike. However, she did have an answer for what each of us ought to be doing now and I call this "Ayn's Objective":

"One has to break relationships with the culture. Meaning, while you live in this society, break all cultural relationships, meaning, withdraw your sanction from those people, groups, schools, or theories which preach the ideas that are destroying you. If you read Atlas Shrugged, you will understand what I mean by the sanction of the victim. It's the situation where the good people are helping their own destroyers and I show how in many ways people are guilty of that, through generosity and ignorance. Men are supporting their own destroyers materially and spiritually, in their private lives and in their public lives."

"Now what we have to do today: anyone who is serious about saving the world would have to first, discard all the kind of ideas, the entire cultural philosophy that is dominant today.
-Do not accept any of their ideas.
-Stand on your own as much as if you had to go into a separate valley like in Atlas Shrugged.
-Stand on your own---your own mind.
-Check your premises.
-Define your convictions.
-Define them rationally.
-Do not take anyone on faith, and do not believe that your elders know what they are doing, because they don't."

"You have to be the responsible creators of a new culture, if there is to be any culture. That is the sense in which Atlas Shrugged is applicable to our period."

"More than that: the enemy ideologies of today---I mean all collectivism and altruism---are so bankrupt that nothing holds them up except inertia and default. People are still mouthing those slogans because that is all they know. The innovators or initiators in the realm of ideas are very rare---most particularly, moral ideals."

"You may observe in the history of philosophy that all ideas change in various periods but morality is the one realm that did not change. Only superficial forms change. Men have always been taught that they have to live for others, and they have to be sacrificial animals or that the opposite would be some kind of brute force, dog-eat-dog situation, in which every man destroys or sacrifices every other man. And, in practice, you see that this dog-eat-dog situation is applicable to socialism and collectivism, but never to a free society."

"In other words, morality is the one issue in which men are afraid to challenge and that is what you have to challenge today.
-Break with the morality of altruism.
-Don't be afraid to assert your right to exist.
-But don't assert it as an arbitrary whim."

"You would have to know how to justify it rationally, philosophically and why you have that right and why if men practice the rational morality of self-interest, their interests would not clash. Men, then, would not have to sacrifice one another, so long as nobody demands or expects or gives the unearned and undeserved."

"If no man regards others as potentially sacrificial material for himself, or for his idea of what would be good for a third party when man drops all those ramifications of altruism then you will see what a benevolent, ideal society one could have."

"Break with altruism and with every idea that is based upon it. At least make the effort to think it out very carefully. You'll be surprised how easily that revolution will be, and how difficult it appears now, but it isn't. Just give it one day's thought, and you'll have a different view."

"Now, I don't mean that's all it will take, I mean to just give it that to consider whether it's possible, after which you will have to do harder thinking that you've ever attempted before because you'll have to be totally on your own, totally relying on your own judgment and the logic of the arguments you hear or consider, rejecting all authorities, all bromides, and taking nothing on faith. But if you try it, you'll be surprised how close the Renaissance is to us. And it's up to each human being to work for it."

For those who want a step-by-step explanation of the process:

People who focus on growth by making a conscious moral effort to improve their understanding of their uniqueness and their responsibilities will see progress. Progress comes from acquiring and retaining truth. This is done with purpose and motion, that is, identifying a goal (or belief) and moving towards it (actively refining the belief). In order to have the energy to make this change, the individual must determine the activities that bring them joy, that is, the activities that give them energy. To do nothing, ignore truth, evade the knowledge, and try to stay in the middle is evil, but everybody is ultimately responsible for himself or herself. Live and let live.

The premise of this novel: it is immoral for someone to use a skill they have to help a needy person which the person in need demonizes. The goal is growth. The needy person will never grow and develop the necessary skill if they demonize people who have it AND are helped by the people who have it. The helpers need to serve the needy by teaching the skill. If the needy don’t want to grow and learn the skill, then the only moral thing for the helper to do is stop helping the needy person. This is the only way the needy person will grow in the long term.

Ayn has written the plot-theme of Atlas Shrugged is: "The men of the mind going on strike against an altruist-collective society." Looking back, Dagny and Hank were completely immoral until the end of the book. They were the problem. People who think Dagny and Hank were the heroes (the solution) have completely misunderstood the premise of this book.

The real goal of ALL of Ayn's writings is to encourage the individual towards happiness! Here is Ayn in her own words (transcript and explanation below):


"The pursuit of happiness means a man's right to set his own goals, to choose his values and to achieve them." (Intangible cause: set your goals and specifically know your values well enough to define them. This is a CONJUNCTIVE. Result: ACTUALLY DOING THIS TANGIBLY without contradiction. Notice, talking about and explaining happiness is NOT DOING something.)

"Happiness means that state of consciousness which comes from achievement of your values." (Cause: getting into the conjunctive of achieving your goals and values..."achievement" means doing something and NOT only analyzing and discussing. Effect: State of consciousness!)

"Now, what can be more important than happiness?" (Unconscious confrontation! Your unconscious has answered this question and now it is looking for your conscious answer and if you don't answer, it will look at your actual actions. If you do answer and it is different than what you are actually doing, your unconscious will make you feel unsettled. If you consciously interpret this unsettled feeling as there being something wrong with Ayn, then you are actually going to make yourself worse.)

"But happiness does not mean simply monetary pleasures or any kind of mindless self-indulgence." (Contrastive explanation: Happiness is not Drift or Evasion. She is showing her definition of happiness cannot occur outside the conjunctive. Analyzing and discussing without actions is "mindless self-indulgence.")

"Happiness means a profound, guiltless, rational feeling of self-esteem and of pride of one's own achievement." (Another conjunctive explanation that results in a FEELING!!!!! We've already defined the conjunctive of self-esteem and how it would be tied to pride in one's own achievement. We've even given an objective measure so people would be able to know how to get there!)

"It means the enjoyment of life, which is possible only to a rational man on a rational code of morality." (Flow: enjoyment of life. Only possible to those who first get to Focus, which is a conjunctive.)

"What that code is I couldn't possibly tell you in a brief interview, but those who are interested in my books, particularly Atlas Shrugged." (Ayn knows her best explanation is in Atlas Shrugged; even better than her taking three hours to give a conscious brain explanation. Ultimately, she knew she had the answer unconsciously.)

NOTICE:
-Atlas Shrugged is Ayn's unconscious answer to HOW to achieve happiness.
-John Galt's speech is Ayn's conscious explanation to how to achieve happiness.
-While writing the speech, Ayn wrote notes trying to come up with a model for psychology.

THEREFORE: It is pointless to try and achieve happiness (or even explain this novel) if a person doesn't have non-contradictory definitions for the various "mental states"!

Here they are:
-Evasion is intentionally focusing on anything other than a "hot-button" thought.
-Drift is NOT focusing on a thought long enough to progress it toward a profitable application.
-Focus is focusing on a thought toward a profitable application.
-Ease is the unconscious trying to make the person's mind/soul aware of a truth through feelings.
-Flow is the toggling between Focus and Ease.

Ayn saw the spirit (soul) of the person to be the first cause; to be the immovable mover. Ayn believed each person was actually INTANGIBLE.

How does the INTANGIBLE cease to exist?
How do you cause the principles of Justice, Right, Non-contradiction, and Causality to cease to exist?

You can't. Only the tangible can cease to exist.

It looks like Ayn believed each of us is going to exist forever.


SUPPLEMENT
"People often think of Christian morality as a kind of bargain in which God says, ‘If you keep a lot of rules I’ll reward you, and if you don’t I’ll do the other thing.’ I do not think that is the best way of looking at it. I would much rather say that every time you make a choice you are turning the central part of you, the part of you that chooses, into something a little different from what it was before. And taking your life as a whole, with all your innumerable choices, all your life long you are slowly turning this central thing either into a heavenly creature or into a hellish creature: either into a creature that is in harmony with God, and with other creatures, and with itself, or else into one that is in a state of war and hatred with God, and with its fellow-creatures, and with itself. To be the one kind of creature is heaven: that is, it is joy and peace and knowledge and power. To be the other means madness, horror, idiocy, rage, impotence, and eternal loneliness. Each of us at each moment is progressing to the one state or the other." (CSL-MC)

"You have the look of a man who accepts what he sees because he is expecting to wake up." (Morpheus, The Matrix)

“For now we see through a glass, darkly; but then face to face: now I know in part; but then will I know even as also I am known." (Bible)

"What is real? How do you define real? If you’re talking about what you can feel, what you can smell, what you can taste and see, then real is simply electrical signals interpreted by your brain." (Morpheus, The Matrix)

"Where the search for the truth is conducted with a wink and nod
And where power and position are equated with the grace of God
These times are famine for the soul while for the senses it’s a feast
From the edge of my country, as far as you see, looking east." (Jackson Browne)

"The Christian Way (to deal with this) – The Christian says, ‘Creatures are not born with desires unless satisfaction for those desires exists. If I find in myself a desire which no experience in this world can satisfy, the most probable explanation is that I was made for another world. If none of my earthly pleasures satisfy it, that does not prove that the universe is a fraud. Probably earthly pleasures were never meant to satisfy it, but only to arouse it, to suggest the real thing'." (CSL-MC)

"You take the blue pill, the story ends. You wake up in your bed and believe whatever you want to believe. You take the red pill, you stay in wonderland and I show you how deep the rabbit hole goes. Remember, all I’m offering is the truth, nothing more." (Morpheus, The Matrix)

Table of Contents

AS 3:10 In the Name of the Best Within Us

PLOT
Dagny, Hank, Francisco, and Ragnar rescue John Galt. They fly back to the valley as the lights of New York City go out. The novel ends with Galt in the valley pronouncing it is time to go back to the world.


SUBPLOT (loose ends)
As Eddie comes back from San Francisco, the train fails. Everyone deserts him.


COMMENTS
Controversy: The final chapter results in two controversies, both of which, help in understanding the entire novel when the tension of the controversies are embraced.

Controversy #1 – Dagny murders a guard. She essentially carries out capital punishment. The crime? "Calmly and impersonally, she, who would have hesitated to fire at an animal, pulled the trigger and fired straight at the heart of a man who had wanted to exist without the responsibility of consciousness." This controversy is resolved by understanding the topics of Causality and Life/Death.

Causality - Remember the controversy of the Tunnel Disaster? It was the result of a causal chain. Likewise, the murdering of the guard is the result of a causal chain which began with: Dagny! Dagny didn't learn through understanding. She didn't learn from the experience of being in the valley and staying. She didn't learn when Hank deserted. She didn't learn from Galt's speech. She habituated to Evasion when she realized people didn't want to live. She looked for Galt when he told her not to (and even told her it would lead to her delivering him to be tortured). She allowed Galt to be tortured, which required him to be rescued from a government who considered him to be a terrorist, which required HER to murder the guard who chose to prevent her from rescuing Galt. It was the price Dagny had to pay for causing the circumstances. It is an unconscious confrontation to all those who want to learn by experience.

Life/Death – Like life, death also has many dimensions. The one-dimensional view: the binary concept, "you are either physically alive or physically dead". The two-dimensional view: you can be more or less "dead". The three-dimensional view realizes "death" is not just relative to your physical state. There is spiritual, emotional, and mental "death" as well. Francisco: "I’ll find them some day, whoever they are…" Galt: "If you do, you’ll find that there’s nothing left of them to kill." Ms. Rand believes the mental state is the most important because everything else is a result of it. Consequently, the guard is mentally dead and Dagny is just finishing the job. Does that mean if someone prevents you from thinking or acting, they are murdering you? What about if someone misrepresents the facts to you?

Controversy #2 - Eddie's fate is left up in the air. On our scale, Eddie was a person in the middle. Ms. Rand left the "mass of humanity" right in the middle of the scale. During a 1966 radio interview, Ayn was asked by a call-in listener why she left Eddie in the desert and whether he died or not. Here was Ayn's answer:

"Eddie Willers in Atlas Shrugged is the symbol, in effect the representative, of the best among rational average men. He is morally as good as the heroes, but he is not a genius. He's a man of average intelligence and a very scrupulous, high moral character."

"Eddie Willers is the first and the worst victim of any sort of dictatorship statism or collectivism. Eddie Willers can only survive in a free society, in a society where the Hank Rearden's and the John Galt's, and the Dagny Taggart's are free to function. He is at his best and he carries his own weight and he works productively in their kind of society. But, he is too good to be able to survive or compromise with a collectivist state. In a collectivist state, he necessarily has to perish. He doesn't have the intellectual or spiritual resources to be fully independent and to vanish or to escape. He cannot stand on his own but he cannot compromise with the evil around him and therefore he perishes."

"The reason why I left him in that position is...I wanted to tell the reader here is the position of the best among average men. If the Dagny Taggart's or the Galt's happen to come along, they will save him. If not, he will perish. But he cannot survive in a collectivist state. So he doesn't die necessarily but his fate is left to the reader. If you do not want him to perish, you better think over your ideas, check your premises and advocate a free society. He needs it more than anyone else. As for the geniuses, they are self-sufficient. They will escape anyway, but Eddie will perish."

The answer is an unconscious confrontation! YOU decide his fate by YOUR actions! If you want him to live then you will make a world where the average person can exist. If you don't work to make a world where the average person can exist, then you want Eddie to die.

Notice, this answer is the opposite of the way Ayn is portrayed by the masses. Instead of saying she only cares about the heroic people and everyone else is bad, she actually said for the sake of the majority of our population, we need to allow the Galt's to produce in a free society and those who don't are responsible for the fate of the majority of people. So, what does Ayn think we are supposed to do until a "valley" is created?

The rest of this post is presented separately as a conclusion to the entire novel...


Next Post: Atlas Shrugged Conclusion

Table of Contents

Sunday, April 29, 2018

AS 3:9 The Generator

PLOT
Dr. Stadler escapes to Iowa and finds Cuffy Meigs in charge of Project X. They fight and are killed when they blow up Project X. The explosion destroys the Taggart Bridge. Dagny calls Francisco after learning Dr. Ferris plans on torturing Galt. Dagny does nothing when she learns the Bridge is destroyed. She takes the Striker’s Oath when she meets Francisco. Dr. Ferris, Mr. Mouch, and Jim Taggart are present while Galt is being tortured with electricity. When the generator dies, Galt offers to fix it. Jim goes insane. Mouch and Ferris take Jim away.


SUBPLOT (loose ends)
Mr. Thompson was slumped in an armchair; he had given up. Chick Morrison resigned.

Dagny packs the bracelet, her five-dollar gold piece, picture of Nat, and map of TT.

Dagny puts on a white sweater Galt requested.

Dagny puts the sign of the dollar in lipstick on the statue of Nat.


COMMENTS
Dr. Stadler – From the perspective of the scale, Stadler was a positive acting like a negative in order to "survive". In the previous chapter, we see the reverse of the other "enlightening" scenes. Instead of the positive person talking and the middle dweller accelerating towards the positive end, Galt said nothing and Stadler drove his own growth. Instead of accelerating towards the positive, Dr. Stadler is actively trying to go to the negative to show Galt is wrong. "I’ll show him that there is no other way to live on earth!" The result is the same. Once again, people in the middle end up dead.

Technology – Project X showed technology doesn't think for you. The ability to "think" differentiates us from machines. Remember all work is a combination of knowledge and tasks. Technology ONLY makes tasks more efficient, that is, makes the user more profitable. In order for technology to be used, the job must be understood so well technology can be created to handle EVERY situation and get a reproducible result. Technology doesn't replace knowledge work. This is what I find so fascinating about Artificial Intelligence (AI). Artificial implies it was synthetically created. Intelligence means the ability to create knowledge. The creation of knowledge is necessary in order to sustain one’s own life. Therefore, AI will be truly demonstrated by a machine that is able to sustain its own life and replicate itself. Do we know enough about how knowledge is created so we can replicate it reproducibly?

Jim – Jim is at the end of the negative side of the scale. What does Jim stand for? What is his #1 principle? "He was suddenly seeing the motive that had directed all the actions of his life. It was the lust to destroy whatever was living, for the sake of whatever was not. It was the urge to defy reality by the destruction of every living value, for the sake of proving to himself that he could exist in defiance of reality and would never have to be bound by solid, immutable facts. Now he knew he wanted Galt’s destruction at the price of his own destruction to follow, he knew that he had never wanted to survive, he knew that it was Galt’s greatness he had wanted to torture and destroy." Jim's #1 is DEATH. Looking back to the beginning of the novel, Jim’s responses make sense. He was all about death and evading this self-knowledge. We met him two years into this process.

Galt – Galt is at the end of the positive side of the scale. What does Galt stand for? What is his #1 principle? "For the moment, their only certainty was that they had to escape from that cellar – the cellar where the living generator was left tied by the side of the dead one." Galt's #1 is LIFE. He’s the creator.

Scale – The scale we created can now be named "The Life and Death Scale". When this graph is drawn to scale from the range of –5 to +5, the vertical difference between the ends seems large. However, when drawn from –10 to +10, the -5 to +5 is insignificant. The goal of one's life should be to continually push towards the positive end of the scale so enough reserves (profitability) have been attained to overcome the day-to-day struggles. This is done by following the unique sound moral code. If a crisis (-10,000 event) occurs to someone in the +5 or less range, it can pull them towards the negative side of the scale. However, if that person has pushed their way up to +7, they remain well into the positive side of the scale. This ability to have reserves (life?) after a crisis allows the person the ability to continue towards the positive side once the crisis is over. Crises will ALWAYS occur. The only way to survive over the long term is to continually grow (produce). An earlier legend said Galt found the fountain of youth but couldn’t bring it down. Galt found the positive side of the scale was life (youth) and it can’t be brought to the people in the middle. Those people have to make a willful choice and go get it for themselves.

Negative Side - Ayn is pretty clear about what she believes was the motive for every person who was on the negative side of the scale: "They did not have to know why they felt it, they who had chosen never to know what they felt - they merely experienced a sense of recognition, since this was what they had been seeking, this was the kind of reality that had been implied in all of their feelings, their actions, their desires, their choices, their dreams. This was the nature and the method of the rebellion against existence and of the undefined quest for an unnamed Nirvana. They did not want to live; they wanted him to die." Throughout this novel, all of the negative people were focused on wanting the positive people to die.

Words – As Jim went insane: "It was not by means of words that his knowledge confronted his consciousness: as all his knowledge had consisted of emotions, so now he was held by an emotion and a vision that he had no power to dispel." Words are the opposite of causeless emotions. Words are "results", objective, controllable and profitable. In this usage, emotions are "causes", subjective, uncontrollable and unprofitable. For example, swearing is an unprofitable attempt to show (or deal with) emotions.


PRACTICAL APPLICATION (worth rereading)
The circumstance surrounding the torture of John Galt is worth rereading. We’ve already addressed some of the topics above. In addition, Dagny knew what the negative side was all about once they decided to torture Galt. "She knew what they intended doing and what it was within them that made it possible. They did not think that this would succeed. They did not think that Galt would give in; they did not want him to give in. They did not think that anything could save them now; they did not want to be saved. They did not want to live; they wanted him to die."

Motive – Their response to killing Galt showed how far on the negative scale these people were. "Ferris’ eyes were blank, Mouch’s terrified, Taggart’s disappointed. Mouch was drawing away, pressing against the back of his armchair. Taggart was sitting on the edge of his, leaning forward." Jim is actually enjoying this display of capital punishment.

Friends – Jim’s cohorts didn’t go insane because they actively evaded the knowledge of what drove them. "Mouch and Ferris did not ask themselves or wonder what it was that had happened to Taggart; they knew they must never attempt to discover it, under peril of his fate."

Generator – Why did Galt offer to help them fix the generator? There are several possible reasons. First, Galt believed in defeating evil with no resistance. Evil is unstable and needs to borrow energy to keep going. That energy comes in the form of resistance. Galt allowed evil to get to its end by demonstrating the least resistance. In an electrical sense, he shorted out the generator. Secondly, Galt believed in the Law of Causality. Things happen for a reason. Why did the generator short out? It could have been poorly designed. It may never have been run that strong. The precise cause doesn’t matter as much as Galt knowing it did happen. He could just do what he did before and it would short out again. Thirdly, Galt knew he had more energy than the generator. He embodied life. It may be at some point the generator actually took energy from Galt and couldn’t handle it. Thinking back to the scale, the further positive, the more life and energy one has. Remember the notes for the first few chapters pointed out how certain people felt more energetic and certain people felt exhausted after dealing with others. If you were to reread the book, you’d see the consistencies with the scale for every interaction in the novel.

Life – The source of his energy may be Galt was willing to "die" for an idea.


SUPPLEMENT
"At some point in the early 21st Century, all of mankind was united in celebration. We marveled at our own magnificence as we gave birth to AI. A singular consciousness that spawned an entire race of machines. Throughout human history we have been dependent on machines to survive. Fate it seems is not without a sense of irony. The human body generates more bio-electricity than a 120 volt battery and over 250,000 BTU’s of body heat. Combined with a form of fusion, the machines had found all the energy they would ever need." (Morpheus, The Matrix)

"But I tell you, on the day of judgment men will have to give account for every idle, nonworking (unprofitable) word they speak." (Bible)

"Again, Christianity asserts that every individual human being is going to live forever, and this must be either true or false. Now there are a good many things which would not be worth bothering about if I were going to live only seventy years, but which I had better bother about very seriously if I am going to live forever. And immortality makes this other difference, which, by the by, has a connection with the difference between totalitarianism and democracy. If individuals live only seventy years, then a state, or a nation, or a civilisation, which may last for a thousand years, is more important than an individual. But if Christianity is true, then the individual is not only more important but incomparably more important, for he is everlasting and the life of a state or a civilisation, compared with his is only a moment." (CSL-MC)

"Because you have been down there. You know that road. You know exactly where it ends, and I know that’s not where you want to be." (Trinity, The Matrix)

"Does loving your enemy mean not punishing him? No, for loving myself does not mean that I ought not to subject myself to punishment – even to death. If one had committed a murder, the right Christian thing to do would be to give yourself up to the police and be hanged. It is, therefore, in my opinion, perfectly right for a Christian judge to sentence a man to death or a Christian soldier to kill an enemy." (CSL-MC)

"Do not fight evil with evil, but overcome evil with good." (Bible)

"But there is another way of demanding results in which the outer world may be quite illogical. They may demand not merely that each man’s life should improve if he becomes a Christian: they may also demand before they believe in Christianity that they should see the whole world neatly divided into two camps – Christian and non-Christian – and that all people in the first camp at any given moment should be obviously nicer than all the people in the second. This is unreasonable on several grounds." (CSL-MC)

“In the first place the situation in the actual world is much more complicated than that. The world does not consist of 100 per cent Christians and 100 per cent non-Christians. There are people (a great many of them) who are slowly ceasing to be Christians but who still call themselves by that name: some of them are clergymen. There are other people who are slowly becoming Christian though they do not call themselves so. There are people who do not accept the full Christian doctrine about Christ but who are so strongly attracted by Him that they are His in a much deeper sense than they themselves understand. There are people in other religions who are being led by God’s secret influence to concentrate on those parts of their religion which are in agreement with Christianity, and who thus belong to Christ without knowing it. And always, of course, there are a great many people who are just confused in mind and have a lot of inconsistent beliefs all jumbled together. Consequently, it is not much use trying to make judgments about Christians and non-Christians in the mass." (CSL-MC)

“For whomever finds me (wisdom) finds life, and will obtain favor from the Lord. But he that sins against me wrongs his own soul: all they that hate me love death.” (Proverbs)

"For the Lord doesn't see as man sees; for man looks on the outward appearance, but the Lord looks on the heart." (Bible)


Next Chapter: In the Name of the Best Within Us

Table of Contents

Saturday, April 28, 2018

AS 3:8 The Egoist

PLOT
After John Galt’s speech ends, Mr. Thompson demands the group tell him what to do next. The only idea comes from Dagny. She says they should give up and get out of the way. As people desert, the government puts out a call to John Galt saying they are willing to meet and negotiate. At 4 a.m., Dagny goes to the address listed for John Galt in TT’s personnel files. Galt is there and tells Dagny to act like his worst enemy when the cops show up. John Galt is taken to the Wayne-Falkland Hotel, where he is heavily guarded. Mr. Thompson and his crew individually try to convince Galt to take over and tell them what to do. Eventually, they stage a televised reception in honor of the inauguration of The John Galt Plan. When it’s Galt’s turn to speak he says, "Get the hell out of my way!"


SUBPLOT (loose ends)
Mr. Thompson puts a "tail" on Dagny that eventually leads them to Galt.

Eddie goes to San Francisco to open up the terminal to transcontinental traffic.

Rearden Steel is destroyed.

Orren Boyle has been confined to a rest home.

The Ferris-Lawson-Meigs faction increases its influence.

Galt tells Dagny to wear a white sweater the next time he sees her.

Dagny now only feels hatred for her railroad.

All of Galt’s inventions are destroyed beyond recognition when the police force the door’s sound lock.

Francisco sends a message to Dagny where he can be reached when Galt will need his help.

Dagny admits to Eddie she knew how he felt about her.

Mr. Mowen is the representative of business during the inauguration.


COMMENTS
Silence – "‘Silence,’ he wrote, with a frown of uneasiness, summing up his report to Mr. Thompson. ‘People seem to be silent.’" The public is silent because they are blanking out.

Words – "It would have been difficult in that distant time when she had regarded language as a tool of honor, always used as if one were under oath – an oath of allegiance to reality and to respect for human beings." Words create value if they are used properly. Dagny is now committed to not creating anything for the world; consequently her words to the world are not profitable (mean nothing to her).

Life – "They were listening intently, but as if they did not hear her words, as if they were clinging blindly to a quality she was alone among them to possess: the quality of being alive." This chapter continues to hammer the concept of life being more than not being physically dead. As was stated in AS 3:4, “life” is the ability to repair/create. Dagny is the only person left among the world that has the ability to repair/create. Throughout this chapter, Dagny repeatedly asks herself about the negative side of the scale: "Do they want to live?"

Dagny - In this chapter, she has officially hit bottom. She has habituated to Evasion, meaning, she feels best when she is evading thinking: "It had been easy, because she had felt as if she were in some dreary non-world, where her words and actions were not facts any longer - not reflections of reality, but only distorted postures in one of those side-show mirrors that project deformity for the perception of beings whose consciousness is not to be treated as consciousness." and "But this - she thought with a shudder - was the state in which they lived, all those people whom she had never understood, this was the state they desired, this rubber reality, this task of pretending, distorting, deceiving, with the credulous stare of some Mr. Thompson's panic-bleary eyes as one's only purpose and reward. Those who desired this state - she wondered - did they want to live?" Dagny told Eddie never to look for Galt, and then she looked for Galt.

Individuals – This is a theme normally mentioned in one sentence per chapter. For example: "It is social treason to ascribe too much importance to Hank Rearden’s desertion and to undermine public morale by the old-fashioned belief that an individual can be of any significance to society." (AS 3:7) In this chapter: "Nobody’s ever said it before! It’s just one man! We don’t have to believe it!" Individuals are extremely valuable. It’s tempting to say this novel is flawed in that the missing people aren’t really that important. How important can an individual be?

Examples – It is real easy to see the importance in the arts. There are some roles we can’t see anybody else doing except for one person. Or songs we can’t see anybody else singing. Sports are a better example. Otherwise, plug anyone into the Bulls after Jordan left or put anyone in the ring for Ali. ALL sports discussions are fueled by "The Value of the Individual."

Celtics - My favorite sports example has to do with the Lakers. Near the beginning of the century, Sports Illustrated named the ’86-87 Lakers as the best basketball team of all time. (I am a Lakers fan.) However, I know the best basketball team should have been the ’86-89 Celtics. For those who aren’t sports fans, the Celtics somehow managed to get the #2 selection in the ’86 draft and picked a player with arguably as much talent as Jordan. His name was Len Bias. Within forty-eight hours of being drafted, he was dead of a drug overdose. It was, supposedly, his only encounter with drugs. What was the result? The star players for the Celtics were forced to play with injuries that year and they never recovered. That’s the hidden (and greatest) value of the individual; their ability to make others more profitable. Why do we think business is easier than sports? There are examples too numerous to list of companies that lost one key person and they were never the same.

Uniqueness – The cause of the value of the individual is uniqueness. The individual in question is irreplaceable because there is only one of them. Uniqueness has been referenced several times in this novel, however it is never really explored. I think this is a glaring omission to the model. Today, we call this diversity. In the preceding notes, I talked about asking Christians about their John Galt destroyer speech. That’s a trap. People are unique, why do Christians have one speech? This ties in heavily with the "Seek first to understand, then to be understood" habit. Don’t just go barreling in with the same speech to everyone. (Ms. Rand’s issue might have been that this contradicted her belief everyone on the negative side of the scale needed to hear the same speech, both from Galt at the end and all the people on the positive side, throughout the novel.) Uniqueness also implies everyone has a value. Yet, it seems pretty obvious Ms. Rand thinks people on the negative side of the scale are too far-gone to have any value. In fact, Jim seems to be hurtling towards the negative end of the scale. "Shut up!" screamed James Taggart. "Why did you say that? What made you say it?" "What made you scream?" asked Kinnan. The only thing left for our scale is a name. This usually comes from the axis. We will name the scale after the positive and negative sides of the scale. John Galt seems to be the most positive person and Jim Taggart seems to be the most negative. As they get put under more and more pressure, their #1 principle will be exposed. John Galt's #1 principle will be the name of the positive side and Jim's #1 principle will be the name of the negative side.

Intangible Cause - Uniqueness is the intangible cause for everything, so it is therefore a "first cause". How that uniqueness is directed determines a person's value. For example, in the movie, "The Blindside", Michael Oher is seen as a great football talent because of his size, even though he hasn't played. When the team gets him on the practice field, he is terrible! Why? He is compassionate and doesn't want to hurt the person he is supposed to block. The mom (Sandra Bullock) explains to Michael how he should see the quarterback as her and focus on protecting her. Once Michael turns his compassion towards the quarterback, he excels and eventually makes it to the NFL. The ONLY difference between Michael Oher being useless on a football field and making it to the NFL was how he directed his uniqueness. Each person on the negative side of the scale has a valuable uniqueness; they've just focused it the wrong way.

Profitability – Profitability is COMPLETELY dependent on uniqueness. If everyone valued everything exactly the same, there would be no way for people to become more profitable. Profitability is the EFFECT resulting from people exchanging value for value, but the individual’s have to value things at different amounts in order for everyone to be profitable. The Creator built profitability into this world when unique beings were created. Love is based on uniqueness. In order for two people to continually exchange value and grow in profitability, they need to value things differently. The source of frustration for most marriages (differences in partners) is also the source of love.

Control - The real danger in believing in uniqueness is it destroys the ability to control people. Think about Eastern philosophy or organized religion, they are preoccupied with removing uniqueness or making rules apply to EVERYBODY. If you truly believe in uniqueness, you have to give everybody more freedom because they ultimately know what’s best for themselves. (This was hinted at during the 20th Century story when they talked about what different people valued for enjoyment.)

Taxes – Speaking of control, "Start lifting taxes and removing controls." If they drop the taxes how will the government support itself? Galt: "Then start by abolishing all income taxes." Thompson: "How would we pay government employees?" Galt: "Fire your government employees." Thompson: "Oh, no! That’s politics! That’s not economics! You can’t interfere with politics! You can’t have everything!" The government would have to focus on delivering value. What value? The values identified in the previous chapter. How would they get the money to deliver the values if there are no taxes? The producers would pay for that kind of value because it’s in their self-interest. (Remember, today our government NEEDS all the federal income tax it collects to run the government. 40% of the population pay no federal taxes. 70% pay 11% of the taxes. It’s almost the “80/20” rule. Technically only the 71st-80th percentile pays their fair share (12%). The top 10% pay almost 60% of the taxes. If this top 10 went away, who would pay? How would the government survive? Besides, this is assuming each percentile is consuming an equal amount of the benefits from the government.) Again, September 11th proved this point. Rich people gave millions of dollars. Why? Because they know they have the most to lose. It’s in their best self-interest.

Government – Who causes the government’s problems? Fortunately, there’s enough blame to go around. There’s a saying, "If you aren’t a liberal when you’re young, you have no heart. If you aren’t a conservative when you’re old, you have no brain." I’d like to add, "If you are either when you die, you might not make it to Heaven." You have to have both. You have to have more heart than the liberals and more brains than the conservatives. Which one should you have first? AS would say you need to have the brains first, because everything comes from it. Then you know why you should have a heart and you know whom to help: people who want to produce. Ultimately, we will be judged by our long-term profitability, that is, whom we help. So the liberals got the end result right. The conservatives have the initial truth right, but they want to stop there. Personally, I don’t hold a liberal guilty. They are like the negative side of the scale, they don’t know better. I hold conservatives guilty because they know better, but they tend to blank out when it comes to helping others.

Dr. Stadler - "You are the man who has to be destroyed!" (Dr. Stadler to Galt) He’s a "conservative". He knew enough to make the insightful "second-rater" speech. Yet, he still blanked out. Galt says Stadler’s guilt is beyond forgiveness.


PRACTICAL APPLICATION (worth rereading)
The discussion between Mr. Thompson and John Galt is worth rereading. It is the practical application of the most important points from the speech. We have referenced some of the discussion above.

"The world is in a hell of a mess. Just as you said. There, I agree with you. We have a point in common. We can start from that." This is how the discussion begins. Right from the start, Mr. Thompson alienates John Galt. Speaking of uniqueness, Jesse Jackson’s ability to bring together disagreeing parties was unique. Although he said he approached it in the same manner as Mr. Thompson, Jesse knew how it’s really done. Jesse started by showing the two sides their different abilities and why it’s in the self-interest of both sides to have a common goal. His goal was to get the two sides connected. When similarities are highlighted, the mind immediately looks for differences. Otherwise, there is no reason for both sides to exist if they are the same. It’s a very subtle point. Things that are similar are separate. They aren’t connected. By definition, for there to be a similarity, there must be two or more of something. For there to be two or more, they have to be separate. Things that are different may be connected. Mr. Thompson would have been better off talking about his value and how it’s different than Galt’s. (Again, Ms. Rand has written Mr. Thompson to have little to no value.)

"There’s always a middle ground. We’ll do anything you say. We’ll split fifty-fifty." Mr. Thompson is all over the place. One minute he is begging Galt to take it all over; the next sentence he wants to retain control over something. This is how some people bargain with God when they are desperate.

Thompson: "Want a billion dollars – a cool, neat billion dollars?" Galt: "Which I’ll have to produce for you to give me?" Galt establishes he is the source. There is nothing Mr. Thompson has of value Galt won’t have to create so Mr. Thompson can give it back to him.

"The removal of a threat is not a payment, the negation of a negative is not a reward, the withdrawal of your armed hoodlums is not an incentive, the offer not to murder me is not a value." It all ends up going through "value for value". Galt establishes the definition of a value. It's the same with God.

"I’ll do whatever you tell me to. I mean it. Literally. I’ll perform any motion you order me to perform." Galt reduces himself to only a task worker to make his point.

Mr. Thompson: "I want you to think!" Galt: "How will your gun make me do that, Mr. Thompson?" The mind is much more powerful than force. Then Galt goes into more detail: "No, you don't want me to think. When you force a man to act against his own choice and judgment, it's his thinking that you want to suspend. You want him to become a robot."

"I know that I want to live much more intensely than you do. I know that’s what you’re counting on. I know that you, in fact, do not want to live at all. I want it. And because I want it so much, I will accept no substitute." Galt brings the "life" concept to a powerful conclusion. According to Galt’s definition of life, the negative side of the scale doesn’t want to live at all. Galt knows there are a lot of things people call "life" that are not as good as the ultimate value. Again, I love to ask people what they mean by "life" and "death". What is life? Be careful with your definition! Is a person who is on "life support" alive? Or is life dependent upon the body’s ability to sustain itself? If so, then is a pure consumer alive? Is life only confined to the physical? What about the emotional, mental, or spiritual? Likewise, what is death?


SUPPLEMENT
"Mr. Thomas Anderson, you believe that you are special. That somehow the rules do not apply to you. Obviously you are mistaken." (Neo’s boss, The Matrix)

"When the Matrix was first built, there was a man born inside who had the ability to change whatever he wanted, to remake the Matrix as he saw fit. It was he who freed the first of us, taught us the truth. As long as the Matrix exists, we will never be free." (Morpheus, The Matrix)

"To one he gave five talents, to another two, to another one – to each in proportion to his own personal ability." (Amplified Bible)

"All Christians are agreed that there is, in the full and original sense, only one ‘Son of God.’ I find a difficulty about the very idea of the Father begetting many sons from all eternity. In order to be many they would have to be somehow different from one another. Two pennies have the same shape. How are they two? By occupying different places and containing different atoms. In other words, to think of them as different, we have had to bring in space and matter; in fact we have had to bring in ‘Nature’ or the created universe. I can understand the distinction between the Father and the Son without bringing in space or matter, because one begets and the other is begotten. If there were several sons they would all be related to one another and to the Father in the same way. How could they differ from one another? (Was Nature – space and time and matter – created precisely in order to make many-ness possible? Is there perhaps no other way of getting many eternal spirits except by first making many natural creatures, in a universe, and then spiritualising them?)" (CSL-MC)

"If the whole body were an ear, where would be the sense of smell? But as it is, God has placed and arranged the limbs and organs in the body, each particular one of them, just as He wished and saw fit and with the best adaptation." (Amplified Bible)

"Things which are parts of a single organism may be very different from one another: things which are not, may be very alike. Six pennies are quite separate and very alike: my nose and my lungs are very different but they are only alive at all because they are parts of my body and share its common life. Christianity thinks of human individuals not as mere members of a group or items in a list, but as organs in a body – different from one another and each contributing what no other could." (CSL-MC)

"In the passage where the New Testament says that every one must work, it gives as a reason ‘in order that he may have something to give to those in need.’ Charity – giving to the poor – is an essential part of Christian morality: in the frightening parable of the sheep and the goats it seems to be the point on which everything turns. Some people nowadays say that charity ought to be unnecessary and that instead of giving to the poor we ought to be producing a society in which there were no poor to give to. They may be quite right in saying that we ought to produce that kind of society. But if anyone thinks that, as a consequence, you can stop giving in the meantime, then he has parted company with all Christian morality." (CSL-MC)


Next Chapter: The Generator

Table of Contents

Friday, April 27, 2018

AS 3:7 This is John Galt Speaking

PLOT
Jim tells Dagny that Hank has deserted. Dagny gets a note from Hank saying he has met John Galt and Hank doesn't blame Dagny. Mr. Thompson is scheduled to speak to the nation on November 22 about the world crisis. His message is interrupted by John Galt's three-hour speech.


SUBPLOT (loose ends)
Mr. Boyle has had a nervous breakdown.

Eddie, Dr. Stadler, and Dagny are the only ones who recognize Galt's voice.


COMMENTS
Model - The model is now complete. This speech is long because it ties up ALL the loose ends. It shows how all the themes are connected in minute detail. This speech is essentially the whole novel, but it is so concentrated, it took 900 pages to set it up. In fact, the reader has to have made his or her own journey in order to understand the speech. This speech could be seen as Judgment Day. However, John Galt has spent the last twelve years removing people who produce through refining their moral code. This is analogous to the Rapture where people with a sound moral code are removed from the earth. The Bible alludes to the Rapture happening in the twinkling of an eye instead of over twelve years. There are two ways to learn: understanding and experience. Dagny believes the world will learn by understanding. That is why she left the valley. Galt believes the world will only learn by experience, however, this speech is him giving everyone one last opportunity to learn by understanding. Throughout the Bible, God always approached people through understanding first. When they chose not to think, He had them learn the hard way, by experience.

Outline - Allan Gotthelf ("Essays on Ayn Rand's Atlas Shrugged") summarized the speech in five sentences. Here are the five sentences with the page numbers from the standard version of Atlas Shrugged:
1. The world is perishing from the morality of sacrifice, and the men of the mind are on strike against this morality, which is speeding up the process of destruction. (1009-11)
2. The proper, rational morality for man is one of life and reason, based on the axiom that existence exists. (1011-24)
3. The morality of sacrifice is the morality of death, for it demands renunciation of that which makes life possible: the mind—and thus of any enjoyment of life on earth. (1024-34)
4. This code is taught by men who, having renounced their mind, seek power over the consciousnesses of other men, by attempting to convince these others to renounce their own minds and accept the morality of sacrifice; the deepest motive of these teachers of sacrifice is hatred of existence, of life, of man, of themselves—and their goal is to destroy their victims and themselves. (1034-47)
5. If all men of reason reject—as we the strikers have—their doctrines of mysticism and sacrifice, realizing that no compromise is possible, and refuse to support them, demanding instead a society of rights and freedom, then the society of the mystics and looters will perish, and then we will have a world of reason, freedom, achievement, and joy. (1047-69)

The titles of each section can be seen as:
1. Introduction
2. Morality of Life
3. Morality of Death
4. Your Teachers (The cause of what is wrong in the world.)
5. Choose Life

One key point that eludes many Objectivists is Ayn didn't have a problem with the Bible. She had a problem with people who teach the Bible, because their interpretation is contradictory. From the beginning of the novel, Dagny and Hank wondered why there was a problem in the world. This speech says the answer is: "People don't think for themselves. Instead, they rely on teachers to think for them and these teachers present a contradictory model for life." The rest of this post goes into the specific aspects of the model for life.

3-D – Everyone knows the physical realm is unfulfilling. Everyone wants to get to the spiritual realm (feelings). The progression is physical to spiritual through the process of thinking. Thinking is the key. Eastern philosophy tries to attain the spiritual by avoiding thinking; they skip over it and say things are unexplainable. This chapter proves once and for all the importance of thinking in order to attain the spiritual (joy).

Proof – That’s why the speech is long: it is a proof thinking is essential to move from a physical focus (where emotions are causeless, i.e., emotions are the CAUSE) to a spiritual focus (where emotions are the EFFECT). Ayn wanted the speech to be able to defend itself for eternity, so with each major section she had to include all the other options and why they are contradictory in order to prove the truth.

Blank-out – This is the ultimate negative response people can have to their only moral responsibility (to think). Now that you are aware of it, you’ll be shocked at the lengths people will go in order not to think. What amazes me is the number of religion experts who won’t address tough questions logically. They just blank out. They feel “what they don’t know won’t hurt them”. When they say, “it takes faith”, they are telling you not to think and just feel. It’s rare to find people pursuing the truth and trying to understand it. "Thinking is man’s only basic virtue, from which all others proceed. And his basic vice, the source of all his evils, is that nameless act which you all practice, but struggle never to admit: the act of blanking out, the willful suspension of one’s consciousness, the refusal to think." We need to make a commitment to pursue the truth and try to understand for ourselves what is the truth. "An inventor is a man who asks ‘Why?’ of the universe and lets nothing stand between the answer and the mind." I'm always amazed at people who let others think for them. "There are two sides to every issue: one side is right and the other is wrong, but the middle is always evil. But the man in the middle is the knave who blanks out the truth in order to pretend that no choice or values exist. In any compromise between food and poison, it is only death that can win. In any compromise between good and evil, it is only evil that can profit. Every form of causeless self-doubt, every feeling of inferiority and secret unworthiness is, in fact, man’s hidden dread of his inability to deal with existence." Blanking out doesn’t make the problem go away. The way to solve problems is to think (recognize patterns and understand) and create knowledge that didn’t exist before. The most popular way to blank out is to let others think for you, hence, the "Your Teachers' section.

Press - There are so many examples of letting others think for you, but the press is my favorite. People seem to think they are getting all the facts when they really get 95% opinion. Another fallacy is if it isn't reported then it must not be news or must not be worth knowing. This is another example of "blanking-out" and letting someone else think for you. "At the crossroads of the choice between ‘I know’ and ‘They say,’ he chose the authority of others, he chose to submit rather than to understand, to believe rather than to think. From then on, afraid to think, he is left at the mercy of unidentified feelings. As there can be no causeless wealth, so there can be no causeless love or any sort of causeless emotion. Observe that he does not expect you to feel a causeless fear."

God - God is Right and Just. I have found every religion believes this model; they are just contradictory in their explanation. However, I found the Bible completely meshes with this model and the tools for determining truth. Atlas Shrugged actually agrees with the Bible.

Bible Notes - In fact, rather than try to hit all the points that are made in the speech, I'd like to focus on a handful of points and show how AS really matches up well with the Bible. The confusing part of AS is Galt is God the Creator, yet Ms. Rand wants to also make him the ideal man (Jesus). God would be the ideal man. However, the story makes more sense if we realize when Galt focuses on ideas he is the Creator and when he focuses on action he is the romantic lead (Jesus). Here are my extremely abbreviated Bible notes.

Eden - Ms. Rand is correct with her evaluation of the immorality of organized religion's interpretation of Eden. However, the Bible is more in line with Ms. Rand. God created Adam and Eve without the knowledge of good and evil, therefore there was no guilt. God said not to eat of a specific tree. They did. Was it the fruit or the act that allowed them to know evil? I believe it was the act. They didn’t follow grace. But they did NOT get kicked out of Eden because of disobedience. God (being moral) asked Adam why he did it. Adam could have done the moral thing: and told the truth (confessed) and repented. Everything that's written in the Bible says Adam would have been forgiven and possibly continued to live in Eden. However Adam’s answer was to ignore reality and shift the blame to Eve. THAT was the cause for leaving Eden. Eve was given a chance to answer God. She could have done the moral thing and told the truth and repented. Then she could have stayed. Instead, she shifted the blame. THAT was the cause for leaving Eden. In the Bible, it says Eve looked at the fruit comparatively. She saw what agreed with eating it. She didn’t look contrastively. Thinking comparatively actually let evil into the world. If you want to know the source of evil: it is comparative thinking. If Adam and Eve always thought contrastively, they would still be in Eden.

Grace Review - Your goal is to modify your moral code to match your unique sound moral code. The ability to recognize and retain truth for yourself (self awareness?) will determine your ability to attain your sound moral code. The extent you let your sound moral code direct your action is the measure of grace you demonstrate. This process is completely dependent upon the individual's ability to think. Understanding there are hundreds of principles, there are almost an infinite number of moral codes and sound moral codes. To take this model another step, the difference between your moral code and your sound moral code may be great or slight depending on the individual. Some people may have very little difference between their original moral code and their sound moral code (like Jesus?). Some people may have huge differences or may have made the differences greater through their lack of acquiring and retaining truth, or just not thinking. Remember, your moral code is proven by what you do, NOT what you say you'll do.

Original Sin - Original sin comes from the fact each man's original moral code is not sound. That is, man's instinct (first response without thinking) is to be comparative (sin). Sin is that which is done apart from faith, and faith is based on experience and understanding. However, it is only sin if you KNOW better. (Recall, Stadler was the guiltiest because he knew better. Hank was the guiltiest man in the room at the party.) If you don’t think, instinct (original moral code) will cause you to sin, but we know better because we have the choice over whether we want to think or not. Ms. Rand agrees with all of this. "Man is a being of volitional consciousness. Reason does not work automatically; thinking is not a mechanical process; the connections of logic are not made by instinct. Man has no automatic code of survival. An ‘instinct’ is an unerring and automatic form of knowledge. A desire is not an instinct." However, organized religion presents all of this the way Ms. Rand says they present it: "Faith is the opposite of understanding and sin is out of our control". The term "Original Sin" is not in the Bible. The way to look at "Original Sin" is to ask yourself, What is the root cause of your (and everyone else's) sin? The answer from the Bible is NOT bad behavior (e.g., Adam eating the fruit). The answer is your response to being proven wrong. If you respond to being proven wrong by thinking comparatively and justifying yourself in pride, you are evil. If you respond by humbling yourself and admitting you are wrong, you are not evil. John Galt said the same thing this way: "An error of knowledge is not a moral flaw, provided you are willing to correct it; only a mystic would judge human beings by the standard of an impossible, automatic omniscience." and "But a breach of morality is the conscious choice of an action you know to be evil, or a willful evasion of knowledge, a suspension of sight and of thought." Ayn and the Bible believe in the same root cause of man's sin!

Hell – The Bible says hell will be cast into the lake of fire where people are in constant torment. Why? Could it be because these people chose not to think? Profitability (creation) is based on thinking about the truth. The people in torment will not create anything. How is this possible? Perhaps God is giving them what they want: blank out. Certainly the constant torment will not allow them the opportunity to think.

Dispensations – God has a specific way for people to remain profitable forever. However, God is Right and Just. If God instituted this plan against the will of the individual, then God would no longer be Just. Also, if God instituted the plan and someone said, “I think it could have worked another way.” God would not be Just. In order for God to prove this specific way is Right, God has to use deconfirmatory thinking to prove all the other possible scenarios don’t work. These different scenarios are called Dispensations. The first involved the Garden of Eden. People had direct contact with God and no knowledge of good and evil. The results showed this scenario was flawed. The second scenario allowed people to live hundreds of years. The thought may have been given enough time, people would realize morality is profitable and evil is not. The result was there was only one moral person: Noah. The third scenario shortened the lives of people after the Flood. The thought may have been having less time and seeing others die would give people a sense of urgency to figure out what was moral. However, it appears these people focused on the physical and built a tower. God mixed their languages and created nations. The fourth scenario involved God finding a person (Abram) and focusing on the resulting nation to try and turn things around, but this fourth scenario didn't work.

Moses – In the fifth scenario, God gave Moses the Law. Before the law was given, people couldn't realize they were wrong until after having guilt immediately after immorality. The Law was given to help people better realize they were sinful without having to sin. It also showed forcing everyone to do the right thing, by objectively defining specific sin, doesn't result in people doing the right thing. God proved being a looter and a moocher doesn't work in the long term. However, the Law itself is truth. This is a subtle point. The Law says lying won't be profitable to you in the long term. (It's amazing how many times the word profitable is used in the Bible.) John Galt says lying makes you a slave and isn't profitable to you in the long term. However, God and John Galt both want to leave it up to the individual to decide if they are going to lie. They want the individual to be motivated from the inside (grace). Organized religion wants to force you not to lie (looter) or make sure you feel bad if you lie (moocher).

Jesus - The Gospels show Jesus as the most purposeful person that ever lived. (Recall Francisco "could always name the purpose of his every random moment". AS 1:5) Jesus constantly talked about profitability and gave a reason for everything He did. In earlier notes I asked, "Why should we be kind to our enemies?" The reasons given in the Old Testament and New Testament are the same, "So we will get a reward". Think about that. Jesus gives us a reason (rational) and a value why it benefits us (self-interest) to be kind to our enemies. (Justice says we all get exactly what we deserve, both good and bad. If we give value to our enemies then the only way we will get what we deserve is from God. Being kind to your enemies is a guaranteed way to get value directly from God.) Jesus was the first person to preach the Gospel of "rational self-interest" (Yikes!). This is the easiest way to fluster a second-hand Christian. Organized religion has told them Jesus preached selflessness, however the Gospels record He gave a value and a reason why it benefits us to do everything He said. You don't HAVE to do what Jesus (or John Galt) says, but it makes you profitable in the long term. (By the way, “The Matrix: Reloaded” states Neo is in the sixth version of the Matrix. We live in the sixth dispensation. In “The Matrix”, Agent Smith says the first version of the matrix was a paradise but was rejected by humans. Our first dispensation, the Garden of Eden, was also a paradise rejected by humans.) So is this sixth scenario a success?

Cross - Most of the confusion surrounding Jesus occurs because people don't determine where they are relative to the cross. When someone quotes Jesus they need to determine if they are prior to the cross (when Jesus fulfilled Jewish Law) or after the cross (when Jesus demonstrated Christianity).

Rapture - Just like in AS, God takes all the "producers" out of the world to prove their value. It's the only Just thing to do. All other religions believe this world needs to be purified by removing the “bad” people. Terrorism is being fueled by this belief. It is interesting to note Christianity is the only religion that believes the people with a sound moral code will be removed and the earth will be left to the people with an unprofitable moral code (just like Ayn wrote). For that reason, everyone else will unite when the sound moral code people are gone because it fits all of their beliefs.

Millennium - During the Millennial Reign (seventh scenario), the Devil is locked up. I know Christians who think that will be Heaven. However, the Bible says after 1000 years the Devil will be loosed and he will deceive people. How? Well I always ask Christians how they convert people. (Basically, what is their John Galt destroyer speech?) About 99.9% of the time it has to do with how to avoid sickness, hell, and depression. Then I say, "It looks like you NEED the Devil, otherwise, how would you explain to people why they need to know God (be moral)?" During the Millennial Reign, people will have to learn to be moral enough to resist the thing they've never experienced. Worse, people may say, “I can do whatever I want and repent in 900 years just before the Devil comes back.” Obviously, this isn't a profitable scenario. The only option is God’s. By the way, is it more profitable to know or not to know when Jesus is coming back?

Joy - Joy results in the creation of energy (life). This is different for each individual. What things do you do that result in you having more energy? That is, when you are done, you feel more alive. These are the principles that should be high in your moral code. Joy is spoken of repeatedly in the Bible. The Bible says it is our strength and is so important it should be tied to something we have control over. "Happiness is the successful state of life, pain is an agent of death. Happiness is that state of consciousness which proceeds from the achievement of one’s values. The purpose of morality is to teach you, not to suffer and die, but to enjoy yourself and live." God very definitely states being moral makes you happiest in the long term. "You who are worshippers of the zero – you have never discovered that achieving life is not the equivalent of avoiding death. Joy is not ‘the absence of pain,’ intelligence is not ‘the absence of stupidity,’ building is not done by abstaining from demolition. Happiness is a state of non-contradictory joy. Happiness is only possible to a rational man." The Bible does give us things to aspire to, benefits and reasons. Yet, organized religion seems to focus on removing negatives. It's a subtle point, but this seems to be inherent in people. They look at things as being less bad rather than short of good. The biggest example is…

Life – "Life is a process of self-sustaining and self-generated action. If an organism fails in that action, it dies; its chemical elements remain, but its life goes out of existence." Galt thinks "life" and "existence" are two different things! The ultimate value to aspire for is life (the ability to create/repair), which isn't the same as ‘not death’. What do most people think ‘life’ or ‘living’ is? "Since life requires a specific course of action, any other course will destroy it. A being who does not hold his own life as the motive and goal of his actions, is acting on the motive and standard of death." Life (like profitability) requires a specific course. "Man cannot survive except by gaining knowledge, and reason is his only means to gain it." Life is dependent on knowledge. "You who prattle that morality is social and that man would need no morality on a desert island – it is on a desert island that he would need it most. Let him try to claim, when there are no victims to pay for it, that a rock is a house, that sand is clothing, that food will drop into his mouth without cause or effort, that he will collect a harvest tomorrow by devouring his stock seed today." Life is dependent on morality. In fact, it is all fitted together at the beginning of the speech. The speech is essentially God telling the individual knowledge that creates life, which is the same as “grace” (the divine influence on the heart and its reflection in the life). The heart of the John Galt speech centers around contrasting life and death:

"My morality, the morality of reason, is contained in a single axiom: existence exists – and in a single choice: to live. The rest proceeds from these. To live, man must hold three things as the supreme and ruling values of his life: Reason – Purpose – Self-esteem. Reason, as his only tool of knowledge – Purpose, as his choice of the happiness which that tool must proceed to achieve – Self-esteem, as his inviolate certainty that his mind is competent to think and his person is worthy of happiness, which means: is worthy of living." (The trinity of reason, purpose, and self-esteem can be seen as being embodied by Ragnar, Francisco, and Galt, respectively.)


PRACTICAL APPLICATION (worth rereading)
The whole speech is ultimately the section worth rereading from the standpoint of the entire novel. I'm going to just focus on four key points.

Sacrifice - Sacrifice means "to kill flesh". However, people use it to mean when they give a greater value in order to get a lesser value in return. When sacrifice is used in this manner, Ms. Rand is right; it is immoral. However, Ms. Rand agrees with the Bible's view of sacrifice. That is, man needs to chose to kill their fleshly, instinctual desires and follow their mind. Another way of saying this is a person needs to exhibit grace: ignore their original moral code and act according to their unique sound moral code. "‘Sacrifice’ is the surrender of that which you value in favor of that which you don’t. If a mother buys food for her hungry child rather than a hat for herself, it is not a sacrifice: she values the child higher than the hat; but it is a sacrifice to the kind of mother whose higher value is the hat, who would prefer her child to starve and feeds him only from a sense of duty." Now the example makes sense. The mother needs to kill her flesh and do what is more profitable in the long term.

Control - "To undercut your consciousness has always been their only purpose throughout the ages – and power, the power to rule you by force, has always been their only lust." It is ALL about control. The Eastern mystics try to control people by getting them to blank-out. Organized religion tries to control people by telling them they can't understand God and need not think. The Bible and God don't try to control people. They focus on freedom. It takes intelligence and character to exhibit grace (divine influence upon the heart, and its reflection in the life), the same as it took Hank to refine and follow his sound moral code.

Government - Government loves to control people. That is not its purpose. "The only proper purpose of a government is to protect man’s rights, which means: to protect him from physical violence. A proper government is only a policeman, acting as an agent of man’s self-defense, and as such, may resort to force only against those who start the use of force. The only proper functions of a government are: the police, to protect you from criminals; the army, to protect you from foreign invaders; and the courts, to protect your property and contracts from breach or fraud by others, to settle disputes by rational rules, according to objective law." The democrats try to control your money. The republicans try and control your social conduct. Neither of them trust (or want?) people to live free. September 11th caused our government to return to their #1 purpose: protection. Remember, a business that doesn’t successfully address its #1 purpose will be forced to address it.

Childlike - It all starts during childhood. "Somewhere in the starting years of your childhood, before you had learned to submit, to absorb the terror of unreason and to doubt the value of your mind, you had known a radiant state of existence, you had known the independence of a rational consciousness facing an open universe. That is the paradise you have lost, which you seek – which is yours for the taking." Is this the ultimate cause of our problems? If so, what is the ultimate solution?


SUPPLEMENT
"I know this steak doesn’t exist. I know that when I put it in my mouth, the Matrix is telling my brain that it’s juicy and delicious. After nine years, you know what I realize? Ignorance is bliss." (Cypher, The Matrix)

"To deny our impulses is to deny the very thing that makes us human." (Mouse, The Matrix)

"The matrix is a system, Neo. That system is our enemy...and when you're inside, you look around, what do you see? Businessmen. Teachers. Lawyers. Carpenters. The very minds of the people we are trying to save. But until we do, these people are still a part of that system and that makes them our enemies. You have to understand, most of these people are not ready to be unplugged...and many of them are so inured, so hopelessly dependent on the system that they will fight to protect it." (Morpheus, The Matrix)

“Over a hundred years ago, Dr. Ignaz Semmelweis noticed that maternity patients were dying at an alarming rate. He made the connection that the patients were being treated by students who had just finished working on cadavers! After insisting that the students wash their hands before treating the mothers, the number of deaths decreased fivefold.” Source: Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (It’s a good thing Dr. Ignaz didn’t decide to ignore the problem and hope maybe it would go away.)

"He looks on men, and if any say, I have sinned, and perverted that which was right, and it didn't profit me; He will deliver his soul from going into the pit, and his life will see the light." (Job, Old Testament)

"A certain man had two sons; and he came to the first, and said, Son, go work today in my vineyard. He answered and said, I will not; but afterward he repented, and went. And he came to the second, and said likewise. And he answered and said, I go, sir; and went not. Whether of them twain did the will of his father?" (Bible)

"If your enemy is hungry, give him bread to eat; and if he is thirsty, give him water to drink; for in doing so, …the Lord will reward you. (Proverbs)

"But I tell you, Love your enemies and pray for those who persecute you. For if you love those who love you, what reward can you have?" (Jesus)

"For the joy of the Lord is your strength." (Bible)

"Notwithstanding don't rejoice in this, that the spirits are subject to you; but rather rejoice, because your names are written in heaven." (Bible)

"Therefore you will draw water out of the wells of salvation with joy." (Bible)

"I am come that they might have life, and that they might have it more abundantly." (Jesus)

"I came to realize the obviousness of the truth. What is the matrix? Control. The matrix is a computer-generated dream world built to keep us under control." (Morpheus, the Matrix)

"Prudence means practical common sense, taking the trouble to think out what you are doing and what is likely to come of it. Nowadays most people hardly think of Prudence as one of the 'virtues'. In fact, because Christ said we could only get into His world by being like children, many Christians have the idea that, provided you are 'good,' it does not matter being a fool. But that is a misunderstanding. In the first place, most children show plenty of ‘prudence’ about doing the things they are really interested in, and think them out quite sensibly. In the second place, as St. Paul points out, Christ never meant that we were to remain children in intelligence: on the contrary, He told us to be not only 'as harmless as doves,' but also 'as wise as serpents'. He wants a child’s heart, but a grown-up’s head. He wants us to be simple, single-minded, affectionate, and teachable, as good children are; but He also wants every bit of intelligence we have to be alert at its job, and in first class fighting trim. The fact that what you are thinking about is God Himself (for example, when you are praying) does not mean that you can be content with the same babyish ideas which you had when you were a five-year-old. If you are thinking of becoming a Christian, I warn you you are embarking on something which is going to take the whole of you, brains and all. But, fortunately, it works the other way round. Anyone who is honestly trying to be a Christian will soon find his intelligence being sharpened." (CSL-MC)


Next Chapter: The Egoist

Table of Contents

Thursday, April 26, 2018

AS 3:6 The Concerto of Deliverance

PLOT
When Rearden’s assets are frozen, Tinky Holloway invites Rearden to a hearing in NYC on November 4th. Lillian shows up when Rearden visits his mother and Philip at their home on the morning of the 4th. They beg Rearden for money. Hank denies them. Lillian tells Hank about her affair with Jim. Rearden attends the hearing in NYC and learns about the Steel Unification Plan. Rearden gets back in time to learn from the Wet Nurse (Tony) about the attempt to take over his mills. Tony dies in Rearden’s arms. Francisco defended Rearden’s mills against the attack. Rearden deserts with Francisco.


SUBPLOT (loose ends)
Philip helped the government with their plan to make it look like Rearden’s workers were starving so the government would have to take over the mills.

The asset freeze was intended to prevent Rearden from deserting.

The Steel Unification Plan is intended to help Boyle recover his losses on his South American investment.

Francisco had been working at Rearden’s mills under the name Frank Adams ever since Francisco left the message on the calendar.

Francisco admits Hank was the "greatest conquest" he spoke of at the party.


COMMENTS
Rearden – The model is nearly finished as this chapter completes almost all of the big themes in the novel by addressing the purpose of life. Rearden has completed his journey. This entire chapter retraces Hank's journey from the beginning of this novel. In previous notes I asked how metal was purified. The answer is "by fire". Metal is made more pure by heating and driving off the impurities. Hank has gone through several trials by fire, each one resulting in a purer (more sound) moral code. During these last trials, he lets go of the last impurities of this world, that is, his family and his mills. Looking back to the beginning of the novel, his only admirable quality was fearlessly pursuing the truth. "To the fearless mind, to the inviolate truth." His personal and professional lives were a mess. However, his goal was growth. He was always willing to seek the truth and adjust his life (moral code) accordingly. We all have the ability to do this; it is in our control.

The Set Up - Ayn believed that superiors were people who thought for themselves, preferred growth, and were moral. On the other hand, the world believes superiors are the people who have money, a good physical appearance, and boss people around. Ayn spends the first 600-700 pages “setting up” the reader by following the weed killer analogy: she writes in a fashion that allows the reader to go the direction the READER wants to go. She does this by introducing a main character (Hank) that is rich, good looking, and bosses people around. Even though Hank fits the world’s definition, Hank is NOT a superior. In fact, he’s NOT happy. The reader that has let the world’s values affect their perspective looks at this “superior” and wonders why he is whining so much. It isn’t until this chapter that the reader realizes while Hank may prefer growth and thinking for himself, he wasn't yet a superior because he isn't moral in his professional and/or personal life, hence the root cause of his unhappiness. Can the same be said for Dagny?

Concerto - The word concerto comes from Italian; its etymology is uncertain, but it seems to originate from the conjunction of two Latin words: conserere (meaning to tie, to join, to weave) and certamen (competition, fight). The idea is that the two parts in a concerto—the soloist (Hank) and the orchestra or concert band—alternate between episodes of opposition, cooperation, and independence to create a sense of flow. A concerto has three movements, which like this chapter, vary in tempo: fast, slow, fast. The first movement of this chapter is Hank's frantic struggle with the moochers. The second movement is Hank's complete cooperation with the looter's meeting meant to slow down Hank, during which Hank solves the mystery of "The guiltiest man in the room". The final movement is a fast moving resolution involving Hank's interaction with the various people present at his mills.

Family - In the first movement, Hank goes back to his house (like Chapter 2) which he hasn't visited in six months: "...and the sight brought back to him the sum of all he had felt in the years of daily home-coming: the strain, the bewilderment, the gray weight of unconfessed unhappiness, the stern endurance that forbade him to confess it, the desperate innocence of the effort to understand his family...the effort to be just."

Lillian – Hank figures out why Lillian married him. "It was for the best of his virtues that Lillian had chosen him, but the destruction of that power had been her goal…as if the vandal who smashed a statue were greater than the artist who made it." (Notice as the characters get put under more and more stress, they will be reduced to the #1 principle of their moral code, because that's all they have left.) Lillian did recognize Hank’s greatness, but she could not equal it. The only way she could feel as great was to tear him down. She believed this made her equal to the greatness of Hank. There are two ways to have the tallest building: build yours up or tear everyone else’s down. Lillian is like a lot of people who feel better about themselves when they find an error in a greater person. In fact, they actively look for an error so they can feel better. Therefore, they treat the greater person poorly BECAUSE that person is greater. If they weren’t greater, there would be no reason to tear them down. Dagny struggled with this in the beginning of the novel. This chapter completes the theme by giving the reason why some people treat people of achievement poorly: BECAUSE the achievers are good.

Forgiveness – In the beginning of the novel, his family mistreats Hank but he lets it go because he does not believe it is intentional. Now he finds out it is intentional. (Remember, the reason is everything.) In fact, the family admits they have mistreated him. They ask Hank for forgiveness. Hank essentially has forgiven them because he gives them no thought. However, the family wants more than forgiveness, they want their conscience eased; they want their guilt removed. They want to pretend it never happened and can only do it if Hank pretends also. The family's definition of forgiveness: "Will you cancel the past, Henry? Will you forgive us?" Hank tells them what is wrong with their concept of forgiveness: "You regret that you've hurt me and, as your atonement for it, you ask that I offer myself to total immolation." Hank does them a favor in the long term by not "forgiving" them. If he had, he would just enable them to stay out of touch with reality longer.

Philip – Once again, value for value is proven. Philip: "They’ve always said I belonged, they’ve always said they needed me…" Claude: "Of what use are you to us without him?" Ultimately, the negative side of the scale always ends up living by the beliefs of the positive side of the scale. Evil can’t exist by itself and will eventually fail.

Unification – Likewise, the Unification Plan proposed during the second movement is a professional way to mistreat Hank because he is good. Again, Hank doesn’t give in to them. Hank then meets with this group that is similar to the group that met in Chapter 3 in the bar. During this meeting that takes place in Francisco's former room, Hank has a flashback to the moment Francisco demonstrated his greatest accomplishment according to Dagny (when Francisco emulated Jesus in the Garden): "Rearden felt as if he were seeing the convulsed figure of a man bent over that telephone, a man who had then known what he, Rearden, was now beginning to learn, a man fighting to refuse him the same request which he was now refusing to the present tenants of this room - he saw the finish of that fight, a man's tortured face lifted to confront him and a desperate voice saying steadily: "Mr. Rearden, I swear to you...by the woman I love...that I am your friend". "

Guilt - Hank then reaches the end of the mystery represented through three tumblers (covered in Practical Applications). The conclusion is Rearden has a flashback to his first meeting with Francisco and Francisco asking: Who is the guiltiest man in this room? "From the first extortion he had accepted, from the first directive he had obeyed, he had given them cause to believe that reality was a thing to be cheated, that one could demand the irrational and someone somehow would provide it." The conclusion Hank reaches is spiritual! "...he could now afford to rest with no further activity of soul." Hank was the guiltiest person because he had enabled evil.

Living – "I’d like to live Mr. Rearden. God, how I’d like to! Not because I’m dying…but because I’ve just discovered it tonight, what it means, really to be alive…" Tony learns what the goal of living is. It's not confined to the physical realm. It means to be profitable in the long term, to create something of lasting value (that benefits/repairs others) with the life you’ve been given. When did the Wet Nurse realize what living is? "...when I stuck my neck out". Thinking back to Francisco and Hank, Francisco tells him he’d give the rest of his life to work with Hank for one year. Talk about "sticking your neck out". Working with Hank is living. At the time, Francisco wondered if he’d ever get the chance to live. What’s the point of being physically alive if you know you’re not going to be profitable; that you’re not going to live? "There’s so many things I wish I’d known earlier." Again, people in the middle of the scale that accelerate themselves towards the positive end too quickly end up dead. "You have learned a great deal in the two years you’ve been here." (Hank AS 3:5) Tony doesn't have the skills to live. We find out the skills to live were taken from him when he was a kid.

Raising kids – "He thought of all the living species that train their young in the art of survival, yet man, whose tool of survival is the mind, does not merely fail to teach a child to think, but devotes the child’s education to the purpose of destroying his brain, of convincing him thought is futile and evil, before he has started to think. From the first catch-phrases flung at a child to the last, it is like a series of shocks to freeze his motor, to undercut the power of his consciousness, ‘Don’t ask too many questions, children should be seen and not heard!’ – ‘Who are you to think? It’s so, because I say so!’ – ‘Don’t argue, obey!’ – ‘Don’t understand, believe!’ – ‘Don’t rebel, adjust!’ – ‘Don’t stand out, belong!’ " Raising kids is a full time job if it’s done right. I’m not one to convince people to have kids who don’t want to. I have always believed "because I said so" isn't a good answer. Parents need to strive to raise kids with value for value. Because kids don’t respond to “value for value” immediately, a parent begins by being a looter and a moocher. The trap is it’s easier and more expedient to stay a looter and a moocher when the kids are able to reason. The example of raising kids is the best place for this model to end, because it is where the rubber meets the road. Ayn writes: "...they sent him to be turned into a tortured neurotic by the men who taught him that he had no mind and must never attempt to think." I’m always amazed by the effect on people’s philosophy when they have kids. Some are stubborn and end up with kids that are uncontrollable. Then they try to explain it away. Most people end up realizing they need to face the truth, especially when the kids imitate the parents perfectly. There's no way to evade the knowledge at that point.

First names – "But first, will you repeat a word you once offered me and I…I had to reject, because I knew that I was not free to accept it?" Rearden smiled. "What word, Francisco?" (Hank was asking if the word was "Francisco".) Francisco inclined his head in acceptance, and answered, "Thank you, Hank." (Hank also calls the Wet Nurse "Tony" before he dies.) Notice, Hank and Frank had their falling out at Dagny's apartment. In this chapter, Hank experiences (references) the only four places he had met with Francisco: Hank's house (anniversary party), Francisco's suite at the Wayne-Falkland (and the ballroom), and Hank's mills.


PRACTICAL APPLICATION (worth rereading)
Hank’s Unification Plan hearing is worth rereading. Hank unlocks the secret behind the negative side of the scale as if it was a combination lock with three tumblers. (Trivia note: In the original printing of this novel, Ayn used the word tumbrils, which is "an open cart that tilted backward to empty out its load, in particular one used to convey condemned prisoners to the guillotine during the French Revolution." It was later changed to tumblers in mass market editions of the novel.)

First tumbler: "You don’t go bankrupt. You’ll always produce. You can’t help it. It’s in your blood. Or, to be more scientific: you’re conditioned that way."

The negative side of the scale doesn’t want to understand the cause; they focus on the result. There is a reason why Hank produces. The negative side of the scale wants to believe it isn’t within their ability; otherwise they would have to be proactive and responsible. Another way to look at this is "Sharing"...as in you will always produce enough to share.

Second tumbler: "Well, after all, you businessmen have kept predicting disasters for years, you’ve cried catastrophe at every progressive measure and told us that we’ll perish – but we haven’t."

I hear some version of this logic in a lot of applications. My response is usually something like, "I haven’t changed the oil in my car for 40,000 miles and it still runs." Or "You haven’t eaten in 3 days and you haven’t died yet." The logic in the second tumbler essentially says, "Abuse it until it’s broken." The problem with that is when it breaks, it’s too late to fix it. That's when reality creeps in. Another way to look at this is "Abuse"...as in we are going to abuse each other (bad things are going to happen) and there is nothing that can be done about it (don't worry about it).

Third tumbler: Rearden says, "There is no way to make the irrational work. What can save you now?" "Oh, you’ll do something!" cried James Taggart.

I can’t tell you the number of people who count on the faceless producers to do something OR reference the past producers without knowing their cause. Their objective is to escape reality. "Those who could not think were to command." What is left for those who don’t use their mind to become profitable in the long term? Either they are pure consumers and make no effort to produce or they are consumers who put on the appearance of producing. Telling others what to do is the most effective way to appear productive without producing. Another way to look at this is "Repair"...as in someone will repair what is broken.

I can model every relationship with: Sharing, Abuse, and Repair. Look at the three types of relationships in this novel. Producer-Producer: both share everything, both recognize there will be hurt feelings, and both work hard to repair by staying logical. Producer-Consumer: Producer shares everything, recognizes there will be hurt feelings, and works hard to repair by staying logical. Consumer minimizes sharing, actively looks to have their feelings hurt, and refuses to repair so they can remain the victim. Consumer-Consumer: Both minimize personal sharing and instead focus on sharing about others. Both recognize others are going to be hurt and say nothing can be done about it so they don't have to repair. However, both want people to repair when they are the one who gets hurt.

Hank wraps it all up: "He was seeing the reason of his love: the mills were an achievement of his mind, devoted to his enjoyment of existence, erected in a rational world to deal with rational men." Too many entrepreneurs think their objective is to build their company up big enough to sell it. It’s only when they sell it off and experience a tremendous emptiness they realize the source of their happiness was closer to Hank’s. Hank's conclusion before he is raptured? "It was the final certainty that his life was his, to be lived with no bondage to evil, and that that bondage had never been necessary. It was the radiant serenity of knowing that he was free of fear, of pain, of guilt." Sounds spiritual to me...


SUPPLEMENT
"And I will bring the third part through the fire, and will refine them as silver is refined, and will try them as gold is tried: they will call on my name, and I will hear them: I will say, It is my people: and they will say, The Lord is my God." (Bible)

"I’m trying to free your mind, but I can only show you the door. You’re the one that has to walk through it. You have to let it all go: fear, doubt and disbelief. Free…your…mind." (Morpheus, The Matrix)

"Whomever's sins you forgive, they are forgiven to them; and whomever's sins you retain, they are retained." (Bible)

"It is moreover a common trait of innovators that they are rude, noisy, rambunctious: Lilburne, Servetus, Roger Bacon, George Fox, William Lloyd Garrison – the list is endless, and it includes saints, artists, and scientists. Tact and reasonableness, loyalty and fair play are foreign to their genius, and it is no wonder that persecutors feel offended twice over, by the heresy and by the heretic." (From Dawn To Decadence)

"Teaching children how to keep promises and living up to their responsibilities is a life-long commitment, according to Child magazine. Ava L. Siegler, director of the Institute for Child, Adolescent & Family Studies in New York City gives these guidelines through the ages:

“Eighteen months to 3 years: Beginning to concentrate – an important aspect of commitment. Encourage pretend play; it offers him a chance to build his concentration skills and, along with it, his sense of commitment.

“Three to 6 years: If a child backs out of a play date, find out why and work from there. This teaches them problem solving and helps them achieve a higher standard of conduct at the same time.

“Six to 9 years: choices. Success here starts before the choice with you helping your child choose something that matches talents and abilities and isn’t too hard to stick with.

“Nine to 12 years: Becoming responsible. The key here is balance. Focusing on fun over responsibility can produce a selfish child. But focusing too much on responsibility without necessity can produce a joyless child." (Gannett News Service)

(You may want to read the notes for the next chapter beforehand. There is an enormously long speech and it can seem tedious if you don't understand the structure.)


Next Chapter: This is John Galt Speaking

Table of Contents